Legal
JP Morgan Contests NY Lawsuit Over Alleged Bear Stearns Mortgage Fraud

New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman has filed a lawsuit
against JP
Morgan Securities (formerly Bear Stearns & Co), JP Morgan
Chase and
Bear Stearns lending unit EMC Mortgage for making
"fraudulent
misrepresentations and omissions" over the sale of Bear
Stearns mortgage-backed securities to investors. JP Morgan
has said it
intends to contest the allegations.
According to the lawsuit, the defendants deceived investors
regarding
the care with which they evaluated the quality of mortgage
loans
packaged into residential mortgage-backed securities before
Bear
Stearns' collapse in early 2008, incurring losses that have
totaled some
$22.5 billion to date.
The lawsuit is the first legal action from the Residential
Mortgage-Backed Securities Working Group, of which Attorney
General
Schneiderman is also co-chair. The group
was created this year by
President Obama to investigate those responsible for
misconduct
contributing to the financial crisis.
In an emailed statement,
JP Morgan argued
that the complaint is "entirely about historic conduct by that
[Bear
Stearns] entity" - that the civil action relates to
Bear Stearns,
which the bank acquired over the course of a
weekend "at the behest of
the US Government."
"We’re disappointed that the NYAG decided to pursue
its civil action without ever offering us an opportunity to rebut
the
claims and without developing a full record – instead relying
on
recycled claims already made by private plaintiffs," JP Morgan
said. "We
will none-the-less continue to work with members of the
President’s
RMBS Working Group and are fully cooperating with their
inquiries."
Securitzations that "turned sour"
According to the lawsuit, at present there remains a further
$30
billion in unpaid principal on mortgages. The Attorney General
seeks
investor damages to recover losses, as well as other equitable
relief.
“This lawsuit will bring accountability for the misconduct that
led
to the crash of the housing market and the collapse of the
American
economy,” Attorney General Schneiderman said in a statement
yesterday.
“Our lawsuit demonstrates that there is one set of rules for all
– no
matter how big or powerful the institution may be – and that
those rules
will be enforced vigorously.
"We believe that this is a workable template for future
actions
against issuers of residential mortgage-backed securities that
defrauded
investors and cost millions of Americans their homes," he added.
It is alleged that Bear Stearns "systematically failed" to
evaluate
the loans and ignored defects which its "limited review"
uncovered. The
bank also shielded the inadequacy of the review procedures and
defects
in the loans.
"Even when Bear Stearns executives were made aware of these
problems,
the company failed to reform its practices or disclose
material
information to investors," the statement continues. "As a result,
the
loans in Bear Stearns’s mortgage-backed securities included many
that
had been made to borrowers who were unable to repay the loans,
were very
likely to default, and ultimately did default in large numbers.